Portland Criminal Justice

Menu
  • Home
  • Crime Logs
    • Daily Crime Log
    • Jail Statistics
    • Year-to-date arrests by charge
    • Year-to-date statistics
    • Terminology
  • Victims
    • Domestic Violence
    • Measure 11
    • Victims’ Rights
    • Victim Resources
  • Defendants
    • Arrest Assistance
    • Booking Process
    • Bail Information
    • Mugshots
    • Hiring A Lawyer
  • General Information
    • Law Enforcement Links
    • MCSO Jail Codes – Crimes
    • MCSO Jail Codes – Holds
    • MCSO Jail Codes – Drug Crimes
  • Jail and Prison
    • Jail By County
    • Oregon Prisons
    • Prison Labor
    • Parole and Probation
  • Contact
Menu

The False Hope of “Autonomous Zones” and Defunding the Police

December 15, 2020December 15, 2020 by Portland Criminal Justice

The recent Portland-area “Autonomous Zone” has come to an end as Ted Wheeler announced on Twitter that he had authorized all lawful means to disband the protestors on Mississippi Avenue.

The news is not surprising given the apparent rise in crime and concern from residents that arose in the immediate aftermath of its creation. According to the New York Times, the Multnomah County Sheriff’s Office reported over 80 calls in the vicinity for fights, disturbances, shots fired, burglary, theft, vandalism, noise, trespassing, and threats by armed individuals.

Although the “autonomous zone” in Portland was an immediate response to the controversial eviction of a black family who claimed they were misled by a mortgage company, it followed the rise and fall of another “autonomous zone” in Seattle this past summer, and its creation forced Portland authorities to act quickly.

Conceived as an island of freedom and sanctuary from police violence and societal limitations, the Seattle autonomous zone, or CHAZ, as it was known, quickly devolved into a nightmarish free-for-all as human nature ran its inevitable course. Residents were kept up at night by loud music and noise while businesses were damaged, vandalized and abandoned. The area was rumored at one point to be policed by local “warlords” including hip-hop artist Raz Simone, though these rumors were later shown as not entirely accurate.

At one point, fear of outside threats from the Proud Boys led to locals openly carrying rifles in the streets, an ironic twist to liberal complaints about lax guns laws. Finally, after multiple shootings in the area that ended with the death of a teenage boy, the area was re-occupied by police to the relief of many residents.

CHAZ was the subject of much misinformation from both right-wing and left-wing media. Right-wingers from Fox News digitally altered photographs and spread rumors about anarchism and violence while amplifying rare events to make them seem common. However, left-wing media declined to adequately report the raw reality of a lack of police, including the loss of local businesses, serious disruption to peoples’ lives, and fear of local residents.

Ultimately the failure of Seattle’s CHAZ to accomplish anything other than alarming local residents illustrates the gulf between fantasy and reality when it comes to cutting police budgets and reducing police presence. In fact, the Seattle CHAZ outcome may have spurred Portland authorities to act aggressively.

The simple fact is that any good and free society in the world is going to have a police force. In countries with no police, individuals are forced to either align with warlords or security partners, or to take defense matters into their own hands.

However, self-policing can be a dangerous endeavor, with the potential to seriously harm or kill other people who are not actually threats. Where self-policing is the norm, such as in unstable countries, people tend to retreat to tribal and “gut” instincts when dealing with unfamiliar people, creating a larger potential for conflict.

Furthermore, individuals who are forced to engage in their own self-defense will have less time to develop other skills necessary for success. They will assuredly be more paranoid and will have a more difficult time building up a society where trust is essential to collective gain.

The motivations for the creation of the “autonomous zones” have not been without cause. The shocking murder of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer earlier this year was a stark reminder of the brutal racism that has cast a shadow over America for hundreds of years and still sometimes rears its ugly head in police forces. The previous killings of people like Eric Garner, Laquan McDonald, and Breonna Taylor contributed to the eruption of anger after Floyd’s brutal slaying in broad daylight over an apparent $20 counterfeit bill.

Nonetheless, the fact remains that defunding the police and removing police presence is not the answer to police brutality. A better strategy would be to conduct a national audit of police forces for white supremacy and hate group members, and to fire or remove those people from policing.

On a local level a more appropriate use of resources would be to create community intervention or community assistance groups of social workers to answer calls about homeless people and nonviolent crimes such as drug abuse. But removing or defunding police invites chaos. It benefits real criminals, enables local militias, and does not improve the lives of residents.

116 thoughts on “The False Hope of “Autonomous Zones” and Defunding the Police”

  1. Pingback: after keto diet
  2. Pingback: discount on priligy
  3. Pingback: buy asthma inhalers online uk
  4. Pingback: hydroxychloroquine success rate
  5. Pingback: is the keto diet healthy
  6. Pingback: doctors using hydroxychloroquine
  7. Pingback: trials of hydroxychloroquine
  8. Pingback: how quickly does hydroxychloroquine work
  9. Pingback: siluman seo
  10. Pingback: hydroxychloroquine youtube video
  11. Pingback: liquid ivermectil head lice
  12. Pingback: priligy coupon
  13. Pingback: can ivermectin get you high
  14. Pingback: plaquenil for wound infection
  15. Pingback: ivermectin de 6 mg
  16. Pingback: deltasone and benadryl
  17. Pingback: stromectol 6mg ear infection
  18. Pingback: stromectol 6mg for humans antiparasitic
  19. Pingback: ivermectin dosage calculator
  20. Pingback: ivermectin liquid oral
  21. Pingback: buy liquid plaquenil for dogs
  22. Pingback: ivermectin in humans
  23. Pingback: stromectol dosing
  24. Pingback: does ivermectin expire
  25. Pingback: ivermectina en humanos
  26. Pingback: canada prescription viagra
  27. Pingback: compare viagra prices
  28. Pingback: ed pills without doctor prescription
  29. Pingback: how to get cialis without prescription
  30. Pingback: hydroxychloroquine for sale on amazon
  31. Pingback: can you buy generic viagra over the counter in canada
  32. Pingback: stromectol for sale
  33. Pingback: generic tadalafil usa pharmacy
  34. Pingback: can you buy viagra over the counter in south africa
  35. Pingback: Anonymous
  36. Pingback: Anonymous
  37. Pingback: Anonymous
  38. Pingback: frontline doctors ivermectin
  39. Pingback: ivermectin price
  40. Pingback: how much does ivermectin cost
  41. Pingback: ignition casino new player bonus
  42. Pingback: order ivermectin
  43. Pingback: stromectol tablets
  44. Pingback: prednisone 5mg tablet
  45. Pingback: cialis pills
  46. Pingback: generic tadalafil
  47. Pingback: ivermectin 8000
  48. Pingback: ivermectin price
  49. Pingback: viagra professional 100mg pills
  50. Pingback: when will cialis be generic
  51. Pingback: purchase viagra pills
  52. Pingback: stromectol tab
  53. Pingback: cialis dapoxetine
  54. Pingback: where to buy cialis without prescription
  55. Pingback: buy generic cialis
  56. Pingback: purchase sildenafil pills
  57. Pingback: cialis cheapest online prices
  58. Pingback: best price for cialis
  59. Pingback: cialis online prescription uk
  60. Pingback: stromectol 3 mg
  61. Pingback: happy family store sildenafil pills
  62. Pingback: generic sildenafil pills
  63. Pingback: cialis tadalafil
  64. Pingback: cialis by mail
  65. Pingback: cheap cialis no prescription
  66. Pingback: buy tadalafil
  67. Pingback: buy prednisone over counter
  68. Pingback: prednisone 20mg tablets side effects
  69. Pingback: tadalafil no prescription
  70. Pingback: covid medicine treatment
  71. Pingback: cialis genérico
  72. Pingback: cialis online in us
  73. Pingback: ivermectin use in humans
  74. Pingback: prednisone
  75. Pingback: exceed viagra and cialis
  76. Pingback: what is cialis
  77. Pingback: online casino real money usa no deposit
  78. Pingback: cialis price
  79. Pingback: ivermectin 3mg price
  80. Pingback: ivermectin over counter
  81. Pingback: slots for real money free no deposit
  82. Pingback: tadalafil and dapoxetine
  83. Pingback: generic sildenafil prescription
  84. Pingback: cialis tadalafil
  85. Pingback: ivermectin human dosage
  86. Pingback: can i buy cialis without a prescription
  87. Pingback: purchase oral ivermectin
  88. Pingback: tadalafil prescription canada
  89. Pingback: ivermektin
  90. Pingback: stromectol amazon
  91. Pingback: cialis without a doctor prescription
  92. Pingback: ivermectin lotion price
  93. Pingback: generic furosemide 20 mg
  94. Pingback: medicine lasix 40 mg
  95. Pingback: can you buy stromectol over the counter
  96. Pingback: ivermectin malaria
  97. Pingback: stromectol 3mg tablets
  98. Pingback: ivermectin purchase
  99. Pingback: ivermectin ebay
  100. Pingback: luckyland
  101. Pingback: stromectol cream
  102. Pingback: horse wormer ivermectin
  103. Pingback: ivermectin online
  104. Pingback: ivermectin uses in humans
  105. Pingback: stromectol australia
  106. Pingback: ivermectin covid
  107. Pingback: ivermectin for humans
  108. Pingback: where can you get cialis
  109. Pingback: ivermectin near me
  110. Pingback: ivermectin use in india
  111. Pingback: japan ivermectin
  112. Pingback: ivermectin human
  113. Pingback: 1rationally
  114. Pingback: otc ivermectin
  115. Pingback: propecia generic buy online
  116. Pingback: can i buy propecia in canada

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

About Us

Portland Criminal Justice is a media and public service website dedicated to providing information about the criminal justice system in Multnomah County, Oregon, and the United States.

Our aim is to provide the best possible free information for victims, defendants, and families of those who have become involved in the criminal justice system in Oregon. We also offer commentary on criminal justice issues both locally and nationally.

We strive to post the most accurate and factual information available. Please contact us if you believe we have made an error.

Recent Posts

  • How to crime proof your house
  • Complete 2022 Arrest Statistics and Highlights
  • The False Hope of “Autonomous Zones” and Defunding the Police
  • COVID-19 update: Oregon prisons on edge after Gov. Brown denies release
  • Jeremy Christian found guilty in 2017 Portland MAX attack

Archives

  • January 2023
  • December 2020
  • April 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • July 2019
  • May 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018

Categories

  • General
  • Notable
  • Oregon law about spanking children posted on February 24, 2019
  • Michael Avenatti Guilty of Extorting Nike, Faces Long Prison Term posted on February 17, 2020
  • Jeremy Christian found guilty in 2017 Portland MAX attack posted on February 22, 2020
RSS
Follow by Email
Facebook
fb-share-icon
Twitter
Tweet
©2023 Portland Criminal Justice | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme